Anonymous asked in Society & CultureOther - Society & Culture · 1 decade ago

whats the problem with the confederate flag?

now,my friend is a rockabilly like know,tigh jeans,engineer boots white shirt and leather jacket....he wears a belt and the buckles a confederate flag? so what?.....why do people assume it means i recll the civil war wasnt fought over was fought of taxes...slavery became a issue at the end of the war,northerners had slaves up until then too? he rocks it cause to means rebellion,if your gonna ban the confederate ban the american flag,the american flag has native americans blood on does the confederate flag with african americans? (and im not from the south,i live in michigan)

9 Answers

  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    With all of the flap and rhetoric about heritage, history and the Confederate Flag it is understandable if people are just a little confused and more than a little chagrined over the whole issue.

    There are those who take to the streets and boldly accuse the anti-confederates of wanting to strip the South and the Southerners of their history and their culture. They wish us to believe that the banner in no way represents racism but does symbolize Southern Pride and heritage. Uh...huh!

    Beware of those claiming not to be racist while engaging in behaviors that clearly defy thoughts of unity and embracing diversity. One must give pause to determine what the true, and sometimes hidden, agenda of these folks really is.

    If we are truly to believe that Southerners wish to cleave to their "heritage," then are we to assume that the legacies of slavery and oppression that are an integral part of that heritage are being held on to as well? Given the association of the Confederate Flag with the atrocities that brought about the Civil War and the post-war usage of the flag, one can only draw the logical conclusion that the flag, itself, is a symbol of extreme hate.

    During the Civil War the flag was used primarily to give the soldiers a means by which to tell their ranks from those of the Union soldiers when in battle. This was done largely because their field of vision was often limited by smoke. But, the flag also symbolized the secession of the South from the nation. Since much of the disagreement which led to this secession centered around the enslavement of people as well as the inhumane doctrines that accompanied such enslavement, one must ask why this "legacy" is one to be fought for.

    All of the Civil War stuff aside, the primary objection to the flying of the Confederate Flag comes from its post-war history. After the Civil War the Confederate flag was adopted by one of the most noted and feared extremist groups - the Ku Klux Klan. The flag could be seen hanging or draped at their clandestine meetings, carried with them to their cross-burnings and lynchings and rapidly became a symbol of the black hearts and white sheets of the marauding gangs that terrorized people of color in our, once again, United States. Though slavery was ended hatred and racism continued to grow and to fester. And, the inequalities and injustices of extreme racism were proliferated by those standing behind or beside the Confederate flag.

    As more racist and extremist groups formed the flag seemed to be the unifying symbol and common thread between the groups and has been and is currently being used by the American Nazi Party, Racist Skinheads, Aryan Nations and a host of other groups. That the Confederate flag is an internationally recognized symbol of racism and bigotry is inarguable. Former ranking member of the Aryan Nations, Floyd Cochran tells us...

    "Everywhere I went in the racist movement the confederate flag was flown. Often times we hear or have been told that the confederate flag has to do with heritage. That is does - white privilege; a heritage that enslaved people and exploited people all in the name of white supremacy and the confederacy. Today in the 21st century, racist organizations know that marching and waving the swastika isn't cool. However, waving the confederate flag is still acceptable to many. In many ways the confederate flag has become the 21st century version of the swastika. The swastika didn't start out as a racist symbol of evil. Its origins are as a symbol of peace and well-being. Over the years it became known and seen as a symbol of hate - like the confederate flag."

    "At Aryan Nations I was taught what the confederate flag represented:

    * 13 stars represented the 13 lost tribes of white Israel.

    * Red was purity of blood.

    * White was the color of our skin."

    Why then are we asked to believe that it is a symbol of "heritage" and "culture" and that it should be allowed to remain proudly waving over the capitols of our state houses? That white privilege is being threatened in America is not in question - it is. That people are no longer willing to accept practices, rites and archaic ideologies simply because they have "always" been there is certainly a refreshing given. And because of these changes the precepts and tenets of the extremist groups, their members and their sympathizers are being exposed and threatened. Hence, a new tactic must be employed. It has been practiced and rehearsed and placed into a three-piece suit. It walks and talks like an upstanding and concerned citizen. It has been given the mantra "I'm not racist - I am a racialist." It has been polished and spit-shined and taught to use "White Rights" as a smoke-screen. And, it found a rallying cause in the Confederate flag issue. Now it is selling the idea of white culture, white heritage and an endangered white race.

    The Confederate flag is a symbol of extreme racism. It's "cultural heritage" is one

  • Anonymous
    4 years ago

    The Confederate Flag is to some a symbol of oppression and to others a symbol of what should have been. I find the flag interesting in it's design but not for what it stood for as it's religious meaning was tarnished by rebel Confederate soldiers who had animosity toward the North and the reunification of the states. I don't mind those who want to have it in your house on your wall but it should not be flown with the United States flag as this country has been united since and that is that. The problem with the Stars and Bars is that Outlaw biker groups, White Supremacists, Neo Nazi's and the KKK and even splinter groups of the IRA, all use it as a means of intimidation and their symbol of hatred for others not like them. Like the Swastika this flag has a religious meaning behind it. But since the South lost this flag has been used for all the wrong purposes. This is the problem with symbols is that over time they are used by groups who find it a rallying point for their cause which the real history of the symbol/s is set aside. If you like the flag then that is you choice but if you like it for what some think it stands for then that is a problem that could divide this country again and this time there maybe more Americans that die than when this country divided in 1860.

  • 5 years ago

    Whatever happened to the American Flag everyone should be proudly displaying? Did we split up and become independent countries that the south forgot to tell the rest of the country about? Really when will people grow up - who gives a **** what color your skin is ? Don't lie to me, don't steal from me, don't look at my daughter the wrong way and we will all live together just fine !!

  • 1 decade ago

    absoolutely nothing wrong with the confederate flag. i'm from southwest virginia and it's something to be proud of down here. it's a symbol for freedom. well maybe not for the blackies but it is for us. native americans fought on both sides of the war when they weren't being killed. i'm 1/10 cherokee. THE SOUTH WILL RISE AGAIN SUCKERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    There is no more confederacy. That's why the flag doesn't mean anything anymore. If people want to make random acts of rebellion on their buckles or T-Shirts. Then why don't they spray paint a giant "A" with a circle around it on them. Now that would get some attention.

  • 1 decade ago

    the confederate flag, oh brilliant one, represents slavery and segregation towards african americans. it's just obnoxious to try bringing it back. it's like rappers saying n____ in their songs. it's totally unnecessary and offensive to most people. everyone knows what happened before and after the civil war, and everyone is trying to move on. some people are just convinced that we need to resurrect bad memories and pain. besides, it was our ancestors that were racist and stupid, not us. some people really don't understand that times have changed.

  • 6 years ago

    @Mariah If you are offended then quite simply look the other way just like I do when I see the pitiful but crack blacks walking down the street thinking they are a fashion statement.

  • 1 decade ago

    it represents a time when there was slavery, and the mentality of the south was racist. regardless of your opinion, to many black people it is offensive, i am mixed, half black half white, and i am offended by it.

  • 5 years ago

    they ll be after the vanilla ice cream next

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.