GIRLS ONLY: Is Michael Phelps really attractive or is it just his body?

I'm a straight guy, but I can tell how attractive a guy is. But with Michael Phelps I just don't get it! So many girls say he is hot, but I just can't see it (I think he has a really nasty looking face). Is it just his body (that I can see, lol), his attitude (he thinks he looks hot) and his swimming skills that... show more I'm a straight guy, but I can tell how attractive a guy is. But with Michael Phelps I just don't get it! So many girls say he is hot, but I just can't see it (I think he has a really nasty looking face). Is it just his body (that I can see, lol), his attitude (he thinks he looks hot) and his swimming skills that make him hot?

Is Michael Phelps like Keanu Reeves - more about what he does than who he is that makes him attractive?
46 answers 46