It's unfair to put these two against each other. For one Derek Jeter has been in the league a lot longer, putting up amazing numbers longer than Reyes has had. And Derek has a bunch of rings. So It's a little unfair. But, Reyes will eventually be better than Jeter. Reyes is younger, so he has a lot more time left in the MLB. Whereas Jeter is getting older and he does not. Reyes is maturing into a better baseball player. He's calmer at the plate, hitting the ball, and coming in when they need him. Not to mention he's the fastest guy I've seen run the bases in a long time. Give it a few years. Once Reyes matures, he will be better than Jeter. But for now (and since I'm a Mets fan I hate admitting this. lol), Jeter is definatly the better SS in NY.