dabest asked in SportsBasketball · 1 decade ago

Put these SF's in order from best 2 worst?

LeBron James

Tracy McGrady

Carmelo Anthony

Paul Pierce

Josh Howard

Vince Carter

19 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Best Answer

    OK let me start by saying T-Mac and Vince Carter are actually SG's( and they are cousins ha ha for real). But for those players I order it like this

    1.LeBron James(EASY!)

    2. Carmelo Anthony(a toughy. But Melo is the best all around player and he has endless potential.)

    3.Tracy McGrady(hard to decide between him, Paul Pierce, or VC but that's my call.)

    4. Paul Pierce(no comment. =] )

    5. Vince Carter( I almost have to take Howard here but VC is a better passer, of course better scorer, but he loses at rebounding tho. VC is gonna put up better numbers because other than Devin Harris there is really no player now that could possibly emerge as stars, but Josh Howard always has solid numbers and he is somewhat more consistent with them then Vince Carter, but on the flip side he has stars around him in Jason Terry, Jason Kidd, and Dirk Nowitzki so his team is better but his stats are not.)

    6. Josh Howard(What can I say he's good with a lot of potential to be better but if we're asking stats wise here I have to take those guys over him, he is not proven to be able to lead a losing team like Carter did in Toronto, Tracy does in Houston, LeBron did in his first couple years until the Cavs got some good players, Carmelo did in Denver b4 AI came, and Pierce did in Boston b4 the "big 3".)

    There's my thoughts for you.

    Source(s): STEVE or ME.
  • 1 decade ago

    LeBron James

    Carmelo Anthony

    Paul Pierce

    Tracy McGrady

    Vince Carter

    Josh Howard

  • 1 decade ago

    1. LeBron James

    2. Paul Pierce

    3. Carmelo Anthony

    4. Vince Carter

    5. Tracy McGrady

    6. Josh Howard

  • 1 decade ago

    LeBron James

    Vince Carter

    Paul Pierce

    Carmelo Anthony

    Tracy McGrady

    Josh Howard

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    1. Lebron James

    2. Vince Carter

    3. Tracy Mcgrady

    4. Paul Pierce

    5. Carmelo Anthony

    6. Josh Howard

  • 1 decade ago

    Lebron james

    paul pierce

    tracy mcgrady

    carmello anthony

    josh howard

    vince carter

  • 1 decade ago

    1. LeBron

    2. Pierce

    3. McGrady

    4. Anthony

    5. Howard

    6. Carter

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    1.Lebron James - 6-9 - Unstoppable in paint but bad shooter

    and awful decision maker but has great lenght and Defense

    2.Tracey McGrady -6-8 - Great Shooter and slasher but not a good decision maker

    3.Carmelo Anthony -6-8 - Great Shooter good decision maker if this guy had a better coach he would be the best SF

    4.Vince Carter - 6-7 - Downgraded due to injuries but still gets his numbers

    5.Paul Pierce - 6-7- Sloppy shooter but gets it in and very slow and a bad decision maker but a very good defender

    6.Josh Howard - 6-7 OK shooter but not a great one and he cant defend worth crap

  • 1 decade ago

    1.Tracy McGrady

    2.LaBron James

    3.Paul Pierce

    4.Carmelo Anthony

    5.Vince Carter

    6.Josh Howard

  • 1. LeBron James

    2. Paul Pierce

    3. Carmelo Anthony

    4. Vince Carter

    5. Tracy McGrady

    6. Josh Howard

    T-Mac would be higher if he weren't so damn injury prone.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.