karl b asked in SportsFootball (American) · 1 decade ago

overrated player in the NFL?

by postition who is overrated

QB

Eli Manning

RB

Edgerrin James

WR

Lee Evans

Terrell Ownens

TE

Alge Crumpler

G

Tony Moll

Roberto Garza

T

John Tait

Todd Weiner

C

Todd McClure

DE

Kabeer Gbaja-Biamila

Julius Peppers

DT

Shaun Rogers

Terdell Sands

OLB

Terrell Suggs

Joey Porter

MLB

Jonathan Vilma

CB

DeAngelo Hall

Pacman Jones

SS

Roy Williams

FS

Eric Weddle

16 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Reggie Bush

    Terrell Owens

    Terence Newmon

    Tony Romo

  • 1 decade ago

    QB: Chad Pennington

    RB: Shaun Alexander

    WR: Wes Welker

    TE: Jeremy Shockey

    DE: Mario Williams

    LB: Joey Porter/Lance Briggs

    CB: Pacman Jones/Asante Samuel/Terence Newman

    S: Ken Hamlin

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    QB- tie between Eli Manning and Phillip Rivers

    RB- Ahman Greene

    WR- Lee Evans, Santana Moss

    TE- Jeremy Shockey

    CB- Asante Samuels

  • 1 decade ago

    QB-Vince Young

    RB-Reggie Bush

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ny21tb
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    QB Phillip Rivers

    RB Marion Barber

    WR Antwan Randle-El

    TE Tony Gonzales (the man can catch but, can't block and, doesn't do a lot with the ball, AFTER the catch)

    the rest are, for the most part, all clumped together.

  • 1 decade ago

    QB-Marc Bulger- he should be on e of the greats if he has two incredible WR, but he hasnt stepped up enough.

    RB-Edgerrin James- deffinately used to be great but people are still expecting too much from him.

    WR-Wes Welker- He only catches passes because moss is being tripple covered.

    TE-Jeremy Shokey - People thought he was amazing, but kevin boss stepped in and did the exact same thing, so maybe it was the qb.

    G-Alen Faneca - Hes still good, but not as good as he use to be, so people are expecting something he cant give.

    T- Todd Weiner- Hes not as good as people think and hes WAY over paid

    C- Olan Kreutz- people are blaming the rest of the bears line on their failure, but hes just as bad as them.

    DE- Shaun Ellis- Not nearly as good as he used to be

    DT-Pat Williams- hes trying to be as good as he used to be and hes failing.

    OLB- Lance Briggs- Their supposed to have a great defence, but they were only ranked 15th this year, and i think hes a big reason why

    MLB- Antonio Pierce- I think Kiwanuka is the best out of the three

    CB- Pacman Jones- Hes been gone for a year, but people expect him to still be amazing

    SS- Kerry Rhodes- Yea, hes the focal point of their defence but hes still not as good as people say he is.

    FS- Ed Reed- Hes good, but people want him to be even better, and its not going to happen

  • 1 decade ago

    QB:Peyton Manning

    WR:Randy Moss,Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne

    TE:Antonio Gates

    i dont feel like answering n e more

  • 1 decade ago

    qb eli manning

    rb reggie bush

    now some underrated ppl

    cb mike mckenzie

    wr greg jennings

    qb david girrard

  • 1 decade ago

    qb- Peyton Manning look at his line and receivers

    rb- marion barber, joseph addai, maroney take away some of the passing game for any of these and they suck

    de- osi umenyiora we'll see how he does without stahan

    dt- Kris Jenkins

    ss- Roy williams

  • 1 decade ago

    QB-Romo

    RB-Portis

    WR- Wes Welker

    Santonio Holmes

    TE- Vernon Davis

    G-Faneca

    Larry Allen ( was beast when he was younger)

    T-Joe thomas

    Matt light

    C-Mangold

    DE-justin Smith

    Mathis (colts)

    DT- shaun rogets

    Pat williams

    OLB-AJ hawk

    Suggs

    MLB- tatupu

    CB-Tillman

    winfield

    SS-roy williams

    FS- Bethea

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.