karl b asked in SportsFootball (American) · 1 decade ago

overrated player in the NFL?

by postition who is overrated


Eli Manning


Edgerrin James


Lee Evans

Terrell Ownens


Alge Crumpler


Tony Moll

Roberto Garza


John Tait

Todd Weiner


Todd McClure


Kabeer Gbaja-Biamila

Julius Peppers


Shaun Rogers

Terdell Sands


Terrell Suggs

Joey Porter


Jonathan Vilma


DeAngelo Hall

Pacman Jones


Roy Williams


Eric Weddle

16 Answers

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Reggie Bush

    Terrell Owens

    Terence Newmon

    Tony Romo

  • 1 decade ago

    QB: Chad Pennington

    RB: Shaun Alexander

    WR: Wes Welker

    TE: Jeremy Shockey

    DE: Mario Williams

    LB: Joey Porter/Lance Briggs

    CB: Pacman Jones/Asante Samuel/Terence Newman

    S: Ken Hamlin

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    QB- tie between Eli Manning and Phillip Rivers

    RB- Ahman Greene

    WR- Lee Evans, Santana Moss

    TE- Jeremy Shockey

    CB- Asante Samuels

  • 1 decade ago

    QB-Vince Young

    RB-Reggie Bush

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ny21tb
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    QB Phillip Rivers

    RB Marion Barber

    WR Antwan Randle-El

    TE Tony Gonzales (the man can catch but, can't block and, doesn't do a lot with the ball, AFTER the catch)

    the rest are, for the most part, all clumped together.

  • 1 decade ago

    QB-Marc Bulger- he should be on e of the greats if he has two incredible WR, but he hasnt stepped up enough.

    RB-Edgerrin James- deffinately used to be great but people are still expecting too much from him.

    WR-Wes Welker- He only catches passes because moss is being tripple covered.

    TE-Jeremy Shokey - People thought he was amazing, but kevin boss stepped in and did the exact same thing, so maybe it was the qb.

    G-Alen Faneca - Hes still good, but not as good as he use to be, so people are expecting something he cant give.

    T- Todd Weiner- Hes not as good as people think and hes WAY over paid

    C- Olan Kreutz- people are blaming the rest of the bears line on their failure, but hes just as bad as them.

    DE- Shaun Ellis- Not nearly as good as he used to be

    DT-Pat Williams- hes trying to be as good as he used to be and hes failing.

    OLB- Lance Briggs- Their supposed to have a great defence, but they were only ranked 15th this year, and i think hes a big reason why

    MLB- Antonio Pierce- I think Kiwanuka is the best out of the three

    CB- Pacman Jones- Hes been gone for a year, but people expect him to still be amazing

    SS- Kerry Rhodes- Yea, hes the focal point of their defence but hes still not as good as people say he is.

    FS- Ed Reed- Hes good, but people want him to be even better, and its not going to happen

  • 1 decade ago

    QB:Peyton Manning

    WR:Randy Moss,Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne

    TE:Antonio Gates

    i dont feel like answering n e more

  • 1 decade ago

    qb eli manning

    rb reggie bush

    now some underrated ppl

    cb mike mckenzie

    wr greg jennings

    qb david girrard

  • 1 decade ago

    qb- Peyton Manning look at his line and receivers

    rb- marion barber, joseph addai, maroney take away some of the passing game for any of these and they suck

    de- osi umenyiora we'll see how he does without stahan

    dt- Kris Jenkins

    ss- Roy williams

  • 1 decade ago



    WR- Wes Welker

    Santonio Holmes

    TE- Vernon Davis


    Larry Allen ( was beast when he was younger)

    T-Joe thomas

    Matt light


    DE-justin Smith

    Mathis (colts)

    DT- shaun rogets

    Pat williams

    OLB-AJ hawk


    MLB- tatupu



    SS-roy williams

    FS- Bethea

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.