? asked in 社會及文化語言 · 1 decade ago

passive voice

i have been stolen the telephone

i was stolen the telephone

What is the diffrence ???

3 Answers

Rating
  • HaHa
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    這兩句其實都沒有分別,都是文法錯誤:

    或許你將steal與rob的用法混淆了,雖然它們的意思有點相同

    steal其後的受詞,是被偷的東西,而用from來帶出從哪裏被偷

    如:She admitted stealing the money from her employers.(她承認偷她老闆的錢)

      He had been stealing from his employer for years.(他多年來一直偷雇主的東西)

    而rob其直接受詞是,被搶刧的人,而用of帶出被刧的東西,如:

    They robbed the company of 2 million.(他們搶去公司2百萬元)

    因此,你的示句:I have been stolen...意思即是:我被偷去了...(即你是被偷去的東西,這是不合道理)

    你的句子應改為:

    My telephone has been stolen(不用from me,因句子已清楚看到應是從你哪裏偷去)

    My telephone was stolen

    其次是have been stolen是用了現在完成式(被動語氣),而was stolen是簡單過去式(被動語氣)

    這兩個時式,其中一個簡單的分別是:簡單過去式,常有清楚的過去時間指示了,而現在完成式,就未有交代在過去哪時發生,如:

    I lost my watch yesterday(我昨天遺失了我的手錶)

    I have lost my watch.(我遺失了我的手錶)

    第一句是:簡單過去式,而第二句是現在完成式,我們都可以看到:

    第一句,清楚交代了過去的時間;也只是敘過去的事實,它與現在無關。

    第二句,並未說出遺失的時間,重點乃放在沒有手錶的現在狀態上,亦即是:這表到現在還未尋回。

    希望幫到你!

  • 1 decade ago

    It's no different= =

    It's no different= =

  • 1 decade ago

    其實我認爲兩個都係唔成立既

    I have been stolen同I was stolen the telephone裏面

    Been Stolen同was stolen分別表示係俾人偷

    之後既野應該係寫係邊個偷

    而唔係object

    但係問題就係o係telephone之前無by

    沒有標明係邊個

    就算有都係唔成立

    因爲telephone 係唔會stole你既

    佢係死物

    Source(s): 我自己個腦
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.