Josaih Leming is way too good for American Idol, because he can sing, write songs, play guitar & piano, and most of all he got his own personality and he has originality. I think that is what a good artist must have; and Josaih have it all. And to be known, Josaih does'nt need the title of being an American Idol winner because he can do it on his own. Especially now that most of the people have appreciate his talent. Maybe, after a year or even months, Josaih's composition will be heard worldwide. And I can wait for that day to come because I know he deserves it.