Are Illegal immigrants stealing our jobs ??? ***Please read***?

This economic argument is used by many people who have never even taken an economics course in their lives. Consider the following example. The manager of Coronaries R Us decides that he can no longer afford to pay $10 per hour to all of his twenty employees, who are American citizens, so he lets ten of them go. In... show more This economic argument is used by many people who have never even taken an economics course in their lives. Consider the following example. The manager of Coronaries R Us decides that he can no longer afford to pay $10 per hour to all of his twenty employees, who are American citizens, so he lets ten of them go. In walk ten illegal immigrants. They request a job. The manager offers them a job at $5 per hour. They accept. Yes, this is illegal, but did the illegal immigrants just take ten jobs from American citizens, or did they create them? The illegal immigrants would now spend most of their meager earnings within this Country. According to the multiplier effect of economics, these illegal immigrants, regardless of whether they pay any taxes at all, would pump on the order of ten times what they actually spend into our economy. This spending would tend to stimulate growth by increasing demand for businesses' products and services.
***Please this is only my opinion Not rude answers***
Update: And consider what happens with H-1B visas. Using the H-1B visas, employers hire foreign employees rather than American citizens. They do this so that they can get away with paying the employees less money and so that they do not have to worry about doing anything productive, such as helping poor people, women, and... show more And consider what happens with H-1B visas. Using the H-1B visas, employers hire foreign employees rather than American citizens. They do this so that they can get away with paying the employees less money and so that they do not have to worry about doing anything productive, such as helping poor people, women, and minorities to prepare for such technical jobs. And this is all legal. It is not people from south of the border who are stealing our high paid computer programming and engineering jobs; it's people who live on the other side of the world who are doing this.
17 answers 17