jared3000310 asked in SportsFantasy Sports · 1 decade ago

Rate my Fantasy Baseball Team?

rate 1-100 and 10 team league

C - Geovany Soto

1B - Carlos Delgado

2B - B.J. Upton

3B - Alex Rodriguez

SS - Orlando Cabrera

OF - Ichiro

OF - Grady Sizemore

OF - Alex Rios

OF - Johnny Damon

OF - Coco Crisp

2B/SS - Julio Lugo

1B/3B - Ty Wigginton

UTIL- Frank Thomas

Pitchers

John Lackey

Aaron Harang

Fransisco Rodriguez

Fausto Carmona

Billy Wagner

Mariano Rivera

Rich Hill

Adam Wainwright

Chien-Ming Wang

Eric Gagne

Barry Zito

Shaun Marcum

5 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    It's a solid team. I'd give it an 85/100.

    C - Soto is a big sleeper this year and may be a huge surprise.

    1B - Delgado is not good. He's old, and a huge injury-risk. Expect similar numbers to last year.

    2B - Upton is great. He's one of the few 30/30 threats at this weak position.

    SS - Cabrera is solid.

    3B - A-Rod is obviously amazing. Probably the #1 pick in the draft.

    OF - Ichiro is great for BA and steals, and Sizemore and Rios are good power/speed combos. Damon is old and injury-prone as well, and is no longer a good SB threat. Crisp has lost his starting CF job in Boston, so I don't know if he'll be starting somewhere else or not. If he doesn't start, he has minimal value.

    Bench - Lugo should rebound from a poor year, and Wigginton is versatile. Thomas is injury-prone.

    SP - Lackey is great, and Carmona and Wang will get lots of wins with a good ERA and WHIP, but not many K's. On the other hand, Hill and Harang will get lots of K's. Wainwright is solid and ended strong last year, and Marcum is solid as well.

    RP - K-Rod is great, and Rivera plays for a good team. Wagner is alright, but I don't like Gagne.

    If I were you, I'd get rid of Gagne. You could improve your OF depth and your bench, but it's a solid team.

    Hope I helped!

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 1 decade ago

    C G. Soto

    Great sleeper, could be very good! B+

    1B C. Delgado

    Sorry, Delgado doesn't do it for me. He's old and kills your team's BA. B-

    2B B. J. Upton

    As redsoxfan561 pointed out, along with Phillips, is the only 30/30 threat in the league. A

    3B A-Rod

    Enough said. A+

    SS O. Cabrera

    Solid guy, expect better BA and HR totals this year. A-

    OF Sizemore, Rios, Damon, Crisp

    This could cause some problems. Sizemore is great, multi-tool guy, hopefully his totals will rise from last year though. Rios is overrated, he's fetching value such that belongs to Mark Texeira. So not such a good choice. Damon is slowly declining too, wouldn't count on him. Crisp is no longer the starter and is washed-up. Sorry, hypeful players, but statless performances. B

    2B/SS J. Lugo

    He,too, is a BA killer and is only good if you're desperate in SBs. C+

    1B/3B T. Wigginton

    He's versatile, and is a good bench player but sucks as an everyday starter. C+

    UT F. Thomas

    He's old and is injury-prone, I don't think repeats his HR totals, more like 20 HRs this year for him. B-

    SP

    Solid staff! Very balanced! A

    RP

    3 solid closers and an insurance in Gagne. A

    Overall: I give this team a 85/100. Your BA really needs an improvement, maybe get Loney or even Helton for Delgado. Trade Rios and Hill for someone like Holliday. Good luck!

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 1 decade ago

    Your hitting is a perfect 10 out of 10 coco and wigginton are your only weaknesses and even they are good.

    Your pitching on the other hand is not so good although you have some sleepers(marcum, wang) overall id give your whole team a 90 out of 100.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 1 decade ago

    Batting is overall good. I would put Pujols on the team instead of Delgado. YOU ALSO NEED RYAN BRAUN FOR THIRD BASE and Dustin Pedroia on second. David Ortiz for DH. Otherwise good. 8/10. Now for the pitching. most are good, but you need Felix Hernandez, Joba Chamberlin, and Tim Lincecum. Take out Gagne!!! hes done. 80/100 before. 100/100 with my changes. thanks.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    i give it a 90 because You lack power. You have some power but it could be improved.

    • Login to reply the answers
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.