Anonymous
Anonymous asked in SportsFootball (American) · 1 decade ago

Manning or Brady?

Whos better 3 time superbowl champ or one time superbowl champ but 2 time MVP of the season?

26 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I'd say Manning. With the receiving corps and OL he has, Tom Brady should win. Peyton Manning does more with a lot less, especially with his top receiver hurt for most of the season. The Chargers game was a fluke, no QB could have done much in those conditions.

  • 1 decade ago

    Brady in a landslide. Brady has 3 rings. The first two superbowls he won with absolutely no running game. He has receivers this year but who did he have when he won a superbowl (troy brown,david patten, david givens). Brady shows up in the clutch. He doesn't get rattled. Manning is a good QB but he has always been surrounded by weapons. He's had Harrison his whole career. He's always had great running backs (Faulk, James, Addai). Manning regular season numbers are better, because of the talent around him and the fact he plays in a dome. Last year when Manning won the superbowl he threw 3 td's and 7 int's in the playoffs. Trent Dilfer had better numbers than that for the Ravens and he is often regarded as the worst QB to win a superbowl. The biggest difference between these two players is Brady is almost impossible to rattle and Manning buckles under the pressure.

  • 1 decade ago

    What short memories people have! One year ago everyone was complaining how badly Brady was playing and now he's Superman!

    Surround any decent QB with an abundance of talented players and he'll look and play like a champ. After all, it is a TEAM sport. This year Peyton's the one with a lack of talent around him.

    Who remembers Terry Bradshaw? He won 4 Rings but he was the clumsiest QB who ever stumbled onto a field! Without Lynn Swann and the Steel Curtain Defense he'd have been forgotten 20 years ago.

    Let it rest until both Brady and Manning are in the Hall of Fame, probably with very similar statistics. There are a lot of great players who never got the Ring.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Brady hands down, any chances Manning had of winning this argument went down the drain in the Chargers game. Brady won Superbowls with no recievers at all, Manning has Harrison out for a game and falls apart. Without the weapons Manning isnt that great of a qb.

    Source(s): Cowboys fan
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Manning is not as good as Brady, Romo, or Big Ben this year. Manning is having an average season, Brady is having a season no quarterback has ever had in the history of football. There are at least 10 quarterbacks who have had better careers than Manning. Brady is the greatest quarterback of all time.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I agree Okie. Peyton is an exceptional quarterback with limited options. Brady has Santana Moss who's as good as the team around him. But I sadly must choose Brady. Right now he is the better quarterback. But we also have to see what Brady will do in the long term. Manning has been in the NFL for 10 years now and has proved he is a quarterback progidy. Brady, though he has won 3 Super Bowls, is new in the eyes of the game. We just have to see what happens in the playoffs

  • 1 decade ago

    Brady.

  • 1 decade ago

    Brady is better, by far.... his leadership brought the Patriots to 3 superbowl wins, with injured teams, and limited receivers, adjusting his game to suit the players he had on hand. Now that he has a first rate receiver corps, he's putting up amazing numbers.

    Manning on the other hand, has always had good receivers, and has only one, superbowl win. And..when his recievers were out, on injury, his game fell apart and he was intercepted 6 times in one game. He can't seem to work without his premiere players.

  • 1 decade ago

    Pats fans are going to say Brady, Colts fans are going to say Manning. Manning runs the offense better, but Brady is just a natural winner. Could you really complain if either one was taking the snaps for your team?

  • 1 decade ago

    Both are good QB's - but a QB is no

    better than the team around him. The

    best QB is nothing if the receivers don't

    catch the ball, or the line doesn't give

    him time to throw the ball down field

    So give the team a little credit also.

    Source(s): rebo mb
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.