Take a look and tell me if you think this player should be in the hall of fame?

I will not use any names just to avoid biast opinions. ( Without cheating and trying to look them up ) Player A is in the hall of fame. Player B is not in the hall of fame. Is player be worthy of the hall? Player A stats 18 seasons Hits - 3,010 Hr's - 118 Rbi's - 1,014 Life time ba - .328 2... show more I will not use any names just to avoid biast opinions.
( Without cheating and trying to look them up )

Player A is in the hall of fame.
Player B is not in the hall of fame. Is player be worthy of the hall?

Player A stats
18 seasons
Hits - 3,010
Hr's - 118
Rbi's - 1,014
Life time ba - .328
2 Gold Gloves
12 Time All Star

Player B stats ( Currently not in the hall )
14 seasons
Hits - 2,153
Hr's - 222
Rbi's - 1,099
Life time ba - .307
9 Gold Gloves
6 Time All Star

Tell me what you think.
Update: I will let you guy know when more answers come in. At least I'm getting honest answers this way.
Update 2: I know it's not all about the numbers. This player was loved by all and was adored by his city.
15 answers 15