Brady or Manning?

Considering Super Bowl XLI, in which the Colts led by Peyton Manning won and considering Super Bowls XXXVI, XXXVIII, and XXXIX all led by Tom Brady, who would you pick if you were an NFL coach and had to pick one of these guys as your QB? Some people say that Peyton Manning is now the best QB in the NFL, but... show more Considering Super Bowl XLI, in which the Colts led by Peyton Manning won and considering Super Bowls XXXVI, XXXVIII, and XXXIX all led by Tom Brady, who would you pick if you were an NFL coach and had to pick one of these guys as your QB?

Some people say that Peyton Manning is now the best QB in the NFL, but that is just from one Super Bowl, and Tom Brady has won 3 Super Bowls. Then again, Peyton Manning has a great arm, but he still always under pressure and mostly chokes when he is under pressure. On the other hand, Tom Brady makes quick and accurate decisions and is awesome in the late minutes of the game and is the best clutch QB in the NFL. Who would you pick?


I think I'd pick Tom Brady.
15 answers 15