Who was on American Idol with Carrie Underwood & Tayler Hicks?

I am not a big American Idol watcher. I usually just catch bits and pieces. But my Mom is a big fan, but we are still arguing about who was on what show.

Was both Carrie Underwood and Tayler Hicks winners? Or did Carrie Underwood win over Talyer on the same show? My Mom says they were on the same show and that Carrie won. I say that it was two different years, and they both won. Who is right?

7 Answers

Relevance
  • Cat
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    MOM IS WRONG!

    Carrie Underwood won in 2005 (4th Season)

    Taylor Hicks won 2006 (5th Season)

    FYI:Other winners

    2002 Season 1 - Kellie Clarkson

    2003 Season 2 - Ruben Studdard

    2004 Season 3 Fantasia Barrino

    American Idol Finalists

    (with dates of elimination)

    Season 1 (2002)

    Kelly Clarkson - Winner

    Justin Guarini - September 4

    Nikki McKibbin - August 28

    Tamyra Gray - August 21

    RJ Helton - August 14

    Christina Christian - August 7

    Ryan Starr - July 31

    A.J. Gil -July 24

    Jim Verraros - July 17

    EJay Day - July 17

    Season 2 (2003)

    Ruben Studdard - Winner

    Clay Aiken - May 21

    Kimberley Locke - May 14

    Joshua Gracin - May 7

    Trenyce - April 30

    Carmen Rasmusen - April 23

    Kimberly Caldwell - April 16

    Rickey Smith - April 9

    Corey Clark - Disqualified April 2

    Julia DeMato - March 26

    Charles Grigsby - March 19

    Vanessa Olivarez - March 12

    Season 3 (2004)

    Fantasia Barrino - Winner

    Diana DeGarmo - May 26

    Jasmine Trias - May 19

    LaToya London -May 12

    George Huff - May 5

    John Stevens - April 28

    Jennifer Hudson - April 21

    Jon Peter Lewis - April 14

    Camile Velasco - April 7

    Amy Adams - March 31

    Matthew Rogers - March 24

    Leah LaBelle - March 17

    Season 4 (2005)

    Carrie Underwood - Winner

    Bo Bice - May 25

    Vonzell Solomon - May 18

    Anthony Fedorov - May 11

    Scott Savol - May 4

    Constantine Maroulis - April 27

    Anwar Robinson - April 20

    Nadia Turner - April 13

    Nikko Smith - April 6

    Jessica Sierra - March 30

    Mikalah Gordon - March 24

    Lindsey Cardinale - March 16

    Season 5 (2006)

    Taylor Hicks - Winner

    Katharine McPhee - May 24

    Elliott Yamin - May 17

    Chris Daughtry - May 10

    Paris Bennett - May 3

    Kellie Pickler - April 26

    Ace Young - April 19

    Bucky Covington - April 12

    Mandisa - April 5

    Lisa Tucker - March 29

    Kevin Covais - March 22

    Melissa McGhee - March 15

    Source(s): ALABAMA...Where Idols Are Born! Proud Member of SOUL PATROL!! WOO! HOO!
  • 1 decade ago

    Yes, they were both winners. Carrie won season 4 and Taylor won season 5. I LOVE American Idol! I think both Carrie and Taylor are talented! My favorite song by Carrie is "Jesus Take the Wheel" and by Taylor "Do I Make You Proud". Hope I could help. :-)

  • 1 decade ago

    Carrie won season 4, Taylor won season 5.

  • kate
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    You are right...Carrie won season 4 Taylor won season 5...the only other people I can remember are the bald dude named Chris who was a rocker and of course, Katherine McPhe who came in 2nd from Taylor....

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    those were two different years. Carrie was going against bo bice and tayler went agains katherine mcphee. Carrie won first and the next season was w/ taylor.

  • 1 decade ago

    They were not on the show together. They were both winners. Taylor won the last one, she one the one before that.

  • daisey
    Lv 4
    3 years ago

    Kelly Clarkson substitute into the 1st to win on American Idol, it could be that Carrie isn't that known through fact the teach isn't watched as lots. Kelly Clarkson additionally made it vast, as did alot of different singers.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.