Who was on American Idol with Carrie Underwood & Tayler Hicks?

I am not a big American Idol watcher. I usually just catch bits and pieces. But my Mom is a big fan, but we are still arguing about who was on what show. Was both Carrie Underwood and Tayler Hicks winners? Or did Carrie Underwood win over Talyer on the same show? My Mom says they were on the same show and that... show more I am not a big American Idol watcher. I usually just catch bits and pieces. But my Mom is a big fan, but we are still arguing about who was on what show.

Was both Carrie Underwood and Tayler Hicks winners? Or did Carrie Underwood win over Talyer on the same show? My Mom says they were on the same show and that Carrie won. I say that it was two different years, and they both won. Who is right?
7 answers 7