Please help with old horror movie title?

Hi, I guess I saw this movie mid 90's.It was a kinda compilation (similar to a kind of tales from the darkside)with maybe 4 or 5 others on the same video. The plot of one in particular was that a couple's car broke down outside an old "haunted house"..only it turned out to be a set up and when... show more Hi,
I guess I saw this movie mid 90's.It was a kinda compilation (similar to a kind of tales from the darkside)with maybe 4 or 5 others on the same video.
The plot of one in particular was that a couple's car broke down outside an old "haunted house"..only it turned out to be a set up and when they entered the house,one of the couple disappeared and pretended to be the "old guy with the shears"from the ghost story.When the other one saw them,they completely freaked out and lifted an axe..just as the audience was shown that it was their partner playing a trick on them,dressed up,facing a crowd of surprise birthday guests!..it really freaked me out.
However,glutton for punishment that I am,I now want to show it to my boyfriend!..so any help with the title would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Update: Thanks for all responses so far,but I had a look at the synopsis for Past midnight and I don't think it is that movie.I don't think there were any well know names in it from what I can remember and i'm sure it was only one of the stories ina compilation movie.Any of this ring a bell with anyone?
Update 2: Thanks to everybody.
It was actually called After Midnight,so thanks very much for all your help.
Much appreciated,
10 answers 10