TOMATO asked in 社會與文化語言 · 2 decades ago

請問這句文法是對的嗎???

有三種的寫作方式不過第三種我有點疑問:

The book whose cover is red is a best seller.

The book of which the cover is red is a best seller.

﹖The book the cover of which is red is a best seller.

6 Answers

Rating
  • Anonymous
    2 decades ago
    Favorite Answer

    這三句不是在講最高級~而是"關係代名詞"的用法

    whose= of which

    例如:

    The house whose roof is red is mine.

    =The house of which the roof is red is mine.

    =The house the roof of which is red is mine.

    而這三句的原句結構是~

    原句:The book + its (所有格 its指the book) cover is red + is a best seller.

    =The book whose cover is red is a best seller.

    原句: The book + the cover of it(這裡的 it指the book) is red + is a best seller.

    =The book of which the cover is red is a best seller.

    =The book the cover of which is red is a best seller.

    所以三種句型都是正確的!!

    第三句也不需要以逗點隔開~

    2005-08-27 12:54:21 補充:

    我因為教學的關係

    文法書很多~您可以參考一下

    1.柯旗化

    2.Azar(敦煌出版~紅~黑~藍~三本)

    3.Grammar in use(初~中~高三本)

    4.Grammar Dimension(高級)

    5.新標準英文法(紅~藍各一本)

    6.旋元佑文法

    Source(s): 自己(老師)+文法書
  • 2 decades ago

    我想請問三號候選人...你用的是哪一本文法書...可以介紹給我ㄇ???

  • 匿名
    Lv 7
    2 decades ago

    cindy_知識初學者 ,

    It's ANNY not AMY...=.=

  • 2 decades ago

    個人認同..Amy..

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 2 decades ago

    前兩句因為有關係代名詞(whose/which)連接主詞(the book) 因此不需以標點符號隔開 文法及句型結構也都正確 (注意:關係代名詞有連接的功能)

    而第三句 因為"無"關係代名詞與the book(主詞)連接 因此需要以逗點隔開 才為完整句子!

    The book, the cover of which is red, is a best seller

    Source(s): myself & my boyfriend from England
  • Anonymous
    2 decades ago

    撇開關係代名詞的對與錯…嚴格來說,這三句都是錯的,因為最高級(best)前面要加的是the,不可以用a!從關代的句子來說,這三句又都是對的!

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.