Trade proposal... would you do this?

Question

My team:
Peyton Manning QB
Hines Ward WR
Vincent Jackson WR
Chad Ochocinco WR
Tim Hightower RB
Marion Barber RB
Heath Miller TE
Kevin Smith RB
Bench:
Mike Wallace WR
Darren Sproles RB
Pierre Garcon WR
Lance Moore WR
Robert Meachem WR
Donald Lee TE
John Carney K
New Orleans DEF
In a 12 team 2 player keeper league.
I have been offered:
Adrian Peterson RB
Baltimore DEF
For:
Tim Hightower RB
Hines Ward WR
Kevin Smith RB
New Orleans DEF

Would you make this trade?
Further info, I am third in my league based of points at 5-3, there are 6 teams at 5-3 including one ahead of me, the order is based of points scored and number 1 is 6-2. I am considering this trade but would like opinions.

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker

whoever offered you this trade is an idiot.

take it before his stupid wears off.

Asker's Rating:

Asker's Comment:

Took it!

Answer 2

def u get 2 players that average 30 poitns a game combined for 4 players that mayb average 40 mayb

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;…

Answer 3

Anytime your offered a consistent 15 points week in and week out guy like AP and BAL D/ST whom is the same as NOR D/ST, you take it. Smith is on a horrible team, Hightower is platooning with Beanie Wells and Hines Ward will fade with the emergence of Mike Wallace. This is a steal. Take it guy. I have no reason to lie to you.

Answer 4

this is not a good trade even though hightower in fantasy playoff time is playing detroit aswell as st louis two horrible teams, Arizona throws the ball more than any team so its a gamble. but u would really want the saints dfense who still have yet to play tampa bay twice, st louis, and washington 3 bad teams. with a dfense like NO they are sure to get good points so if u can get the saints D get it but dont trade AP.