Which series do you prefer? Lord of the Rings or Narnia?

Question

Which of these 2 fantasy series is better? Please don't reply saying that "Tolkein and Lewis are friends" and all that stuff. We all know they both are friends and shared ideas. But I just want to compare to see what do you guys prefer

And also, who would win a fight between these characters?

Frodo Baggins or Lucy Pevensie? (Heroes who are weak)

Legolas or Susan Pevensie? (Archers)

Gimli or Edmund Pevensie? (Warriors)

Aragorn or Peter Pevensie? (Warriors)

Saruman or The White Witch? (Wicked wizards and witches)


and which battles are better?

The Battle of Helm's Deep (LotR-The 2 Towers) vs The Battle between The Telmarines and Narnians (TCON-Prince Caspian)?

The Battle between Mordor and Gondor (LotR-Return of the King) vs The Battle between The Narnians and The White Witch's Army (TCON-Lion, Witch Wardrobe)?

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Voters

i like the chronicles of Narnia more. didn't exactly put me to sleep. between the characters i don't know who would win. however i would like to point out to those would had put that the Pevensies are young and inexperience that you haven't factor in all the time that they spent in Narnia. i mean they were there the entire Golden Age of Narnia (b/c they're the one who started it of course) until they forgot where they were actually from. and only stumble back to the wardrobe by accident. but whatever, everyone has their own opinion.

Answer 2

Narnia. it did not put me to sleep. i have LOTR series, but i only read the first 2 and then i got bored. i was young when i read both tho.

Answer 3

definitely the narnia.

and uhm, i'm not quite sure.

Answer 4

narnia

Answer 5

Wow...

Lotr though...def.
Narnia is very good also..LOTR just caught my interests more.

Answer 6

I think it all depends on your taste. Narnia are kids books, and lord of the rings are more for adults, but they are both good...

BTW don't ask questions like: WHO WOULD WIN? because thats just gay

Answer 7

I'm with Narnia all the way

Answer 8

lord of the rings is better,
and...
fights:
1. Lucy
2. Legolas becuase he was sooooooo perfect and never missed in the lord of the rings
3. Gimli
4. Aragorn, because peter just points the sword at you and yells "STOPP"
5. Saruman

Battles:
1. Helms Deep because i didn't see the other narnia
2. Mordor and Gondor

(:

Answer 9

I liked the Narnia series better. I liked how kids were the main characters. The Lord of the Rings was to complex and boring. I think all of the Narnia characters were better. For once, I witch was the big bad guy. I have to admit though, The Lord of the Rings battles were intense.

Answer 10

narnia is better

Answer 11

Lord of the Rings is way better. i love narnia but i think its too child like to match up to Rings. i think anyone from LOTR would win anyone from narnia mainly because. they have years of experience in battle. the other kids walked in an old closet one time and that's their experience. as for frodo and susan frodo would win only because of age. and saruman would win the white witch cause he's smarter.

Answer 12

I am going to say The Lord of the Rings series because they had more action in it and I thought the plot and characters were better. I believe that Frodo could beat Lucy. Legolas could definitely beat Susan no questions asked. Gimli could beat Edmund and Aragorn could definitely beat Peter. They are all experienced fighters, the kids are not. Saruman definitely could beat the white witch because he has more powers. The Battle of Helm's Deep definitely the is like the greatest battle ever. The Battle between Mordor and Gondor.

Source(s):

Like both movies but the Lord of the Rings is better.

Answer 13

The Lord of the Rings for sure!!! I hate the narnia movies with a passion!!

Answer 14

talking strictly movies here, but the lord of the rings movies are waaaaaaaaaaaay better. theres no competition whatsoever. they arent my favourite movies but i cant deny that they are tremendously well made and watching them is like living in their world. they have great characters and the battles are some of the movie stirring scenes in movie history. narnia was flat and bloodless and felt like a kids version of lotr. when it comes to the books, i still prefer lotr, but the distinction isnt as obvious as with the movies