Breaking Dawn critcisms? (Spolier, don't open if you haven't read it yet!)?

Question

I read Breaking Dawn and I was looking online and reading reviews for it and some people were saying that when Bella had sex with Edward and got pregnant with Renesmee that it was a bad influence toward teenage girls. I TOTALLY dissagree with this statement because she was MARRIED when her and Edward had sex and Edward said he wanted to wait anyway. Who agrees with me on this?

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Voters

Just because you're married doesn't mean having a kid at 18 is the greatest idea ever. The fact that he covered her in bruises, and she was still begging for sex was more of a bad influence for kids.

Answer 2

yea i agree and the only reason she got married so young (even though she was an adult) was that she was going to live forever anyway. so she had like eternity to go to collage and stuff. there are alot of factors of the book that are unrealistic and u cant really look at these ppl as role modles bc there vampires and u will nvr do haf the things they do simply bc u cant.

Answer 3

yea i totally agree cause like you said they were married and its not like she give ANY detail (thou we ALLL would have liked that)

Answer 4

Yes i totally agree!!! People are sooooo stupid sometimes!
UGH! She was pushing him but he told her no a lot! Then after they were married they had sex....and on their honeymoon! So if people think that people dont have sex on their honeymoon then wow they need a reality check! And Bella was at a right age and Edward was at a completely right age.....they both waited long enough. Lol

Source(s):

read and loved the books!!!

Answer 5

That's not what I disagreed with, it was the fact that it felt like reading sugary-sweet fan fiction.

Seriously.

What happened to smart, intelligent Bella? She became a simpering idiot. What happened to romantic if slightly over-possessive Edward? He asked Jacob to impregnate Bella!

And "Renesmee"? That sounds like a name a 13 year old would make up, not a well-read woman.