Jacob Black: Love him or Loathe him?

Question

I haven't read BD yet, is it true that he RUINS it??? :'(

What are your opinions of Jacob??

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Voters

He's an a**hole. I loathe him. And this is coming from a fan of Jacob Black--previously. He's a pedophile, for crying out loud! That's disgusting.

Answer 2

NO I don't think he ruins it. I actually like what Stephenie Meyer does with him. He's kind of annoying in the middle of the book, but later on once the big thing with him happens, he's just sweet.

I think he can be a jerk. I didn't like him in New Moon. In Eclipse, I was angry at Edward and didn't like Jacob. Now, I like both.

Answer 3

Well, in my opinion he saves the book- I think I enjoyed his point of view the best. While the ending of breaking dawn might have been too "happy" for some, and many will be moaning about how the series is ruined (i won't post any spoilers), it was an...intresting book. It wasn't my fav, but it wasn't the worst.

Answer 4

I like him better then edward

Answer 5

hes a good friend to bella !
he was there when no one else was :[
and for that i think we are great ful!
so i think you should love him!

Answer 6

HE dosn't ruin it. SM did.

Answer 7

I don't like him or hate him, but he can not be with Bella. If he was the book just wouldn't be right. He's too immature.

Answer 8

I love him. I hate Edward. Edward is so "perfect" and "God-like" it makes me throw up a little in my mouth.

He's more believable, he's more LOVEABLE! Bella never loved Edward, she was merely addicted to him. ADDICTED to him like a heroin addict is addicted to heroin.

Answer 9

yeah... don't know who that is.

Answer 10

No, he doesn't ruin it. I used to be a HUGE Jacob Black fan, all Team Jacob and stuff like that. But..when I read Breaking Dawn..I wasn't sure how to feel about him anymore. I mean, he seems like a pedophile! I was okay with the part with his narrating the story, but only because I despise Bella and her whinyness. The whole I'LL HAVE SEX WITH YOU, BELLA! thing he had going was a little over the top, and I don't think that the old Edward would have let him do that. I think Edward maybe ruined it a little bit, because he CHANGED so much from Twlight, New Moon and Eclipse. I don't know. I thought Jacob was OKAY, but is he my favorite character anymore? Not really. I don't really have one anymore.

Answer 11

I just felt like his presence was missing, because after the baby is born so is the attraction between him and Bella.

I didn't want her to end up with Jacob, but I do think that their "love" was part of what made the books so good, after Jacob imprints on the baby, he is kind of lost as a person. He isn't the same character that he was in the other books, so that kind of ruined it for me. I wanted him to be more present than he was.