Why do so many Muslims disagree with their Allah?

Question

Allah says your God is my God and it is obvious they are not the same God many Muslims agree, if this word of Allah is not true why believe Allah at all? He would have to exist before Muhammad and yet there is no evidence of his existance until after Muhammad.

Additional Details

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;…

Rivert, respectfully speaking Abraham taught that the lord would provide himself a lamb...Moses taught of the tree of life... Isaiah said the Messiah would be a lamb of God and atone for sin...Jesus agreed and said no man comes to the Father but through the son and that the Father and Son were one.
John the Baptist did anounce Christ as the lamb of God...these are the prophets of God you think that Allah is the God of?

Muslim If you do not believe in the diety of Jesus you do not believe in Jesus.

Adamjer I am Christian and I believe in One God. The idea of Muhamamd that the tinity is somehow refering to more than one God does prove Muhammad did not know the true God. god is Father son and Holy Spirit and they are one God. We are created int his image of God and we also are more than one part. God made man in this image having both flesh and spirit and the two are yet one man. It is the eternal spirit that makes man in God's image. Allah did not understand this truth of the God that existed before him and is a definite flaw that he claims to be the same God.

jenn you are exactly what I am speaking of. Did Allah say he was the God that was before Muhammad the God of Abraham? yet you say he is not this God? Do you intend to explain to your god that he is wrong? I definitely agree with you but in truth this makes your god a liar or non existant.

Muhammad, The name Allah does not make Allah god any more than the name Muslim makes one in submission to god. If I call my dog Allah it does not make my dog the creator does it? No it is simply a name. The true god i more than simply a name God he is the true creator of all that exist and he is not ina greement wiht the Allah of Islam. It is the reason many like some who have answered here aknowledge they are not the same god... if theya re not the same god then we need to figure why Allah is claiming to be a god he is not in agreement with and we have no history of this God before Muhammad...Muhammad could not have created him or he would not be the creator of the world...

Sorry Jenn I misinterpreted what you were saying..you believe the Christian God is the same as the Allah of Islam.
Which I find very interesting though I disagree strongly you are in agreement with your Allah. Allah of Islam teaches that Chrsit is not the savior yet Moses and Abrham and Isaiah and Jesus teach differently...not sure how these are the same god.

Moon appreciate your answer. The fact that Muhammad as well as Muslim miss in the trinity is that God is indeed one Christian worship one God. Moses gave us the answer to this in the first scriptures God gave us. God shows us his creation in Genesis and how man was created in his image and did fall from God's righteousness and how this equaled death. The image of God is reflected in our creation and mose did show how man was created above the animals in the image of God being both flesh and spirit and these are one man.
We are not seprerate beings butr we do have a body and a spirit and these do make up one living soul. God is not more than one God and yet he ahs parts which are Father and Son and Holy Spirit and these p[arts do make up one God... If Moses understood this and God who gave him this understanding did give us this in his first scriptures why would God forget this? surely Muhammad did not understand this meaning of the trinity which makes us wonder how Muhamamd could

have been speaking with the same God that Moses spoke with...these are not the same God yet Allah says theya re the same God... this dear friend is my problem with Muhammad and Allah.

Flames...when Moses gave man the first scriptures of God was he wrong?
Moses in Genesis say God said " Let us create man in our image" He goes on to show this creation in teh image of God to be a man having both spirit and flesh and these two are one man..one soul... man is created in the image of God with more than one part. Mose understood this image of God which made man one but having both body and spirit Moses clearly understood the trinity meant one God and yet Muhammad understood the trinity to mean more than one God...how can God give this truth to Moses and yet not reveal this truth to Muhammad? Muhammads message is not the same as the message given to the prophets of God.

Humble, this is nothing more than a word game...if i concede Allah is the Arabic meaning of the word god..It does not make the Allah of Islam the God of Abraham.

Masha If Allah revealed his truth to Moses and Muhammad why are the books of Moses not in agreement with Muhammad's Quran? Why are the prophets of God before Muhammad not in agreement with Muhammad? the Qu;ran says it is in agreement wiht the prophets of God and yet they are clearly not in agreeement. If this is the same God would he not agee with himself?

Syeed, Is this the teachings of Alalh that each scripture and prophet was only for a certain time? I am not so sure that is his teaching but it was not the teaching of the god that existed before Muhammad... his word will endure forever. If I recall from the Qu'ran 6 114 115 it says that the word of Allah never changes... and why should the word of an all knowing God change?

angel of faith when alalh says say to the people of the book we agree wiht the revealtion ahnded down to you..Your God is My God he didnt mean we had the same God? only that we worship God and he never implied he was the God of Abraham and Moses and Jesus thatw as worshiped before Muhammad?

now angel of faith says we have different God;s and denies Allah intends to be thought of as the God that Chrisitans worship... this is what I mean by Muslism seem to disagree with their Allah. I agree wiht you angel they are different gods but why does your God want to be my God? He says he si the God of Abraham and we both know he is not...does this make Allah a liar? and when did he come into existance?

Asad He is the same God of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Ismail, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Aaron, Zachariah, Mary, John, Jesus and Mohammad?
Do you have the written words of any of these who are in agreement with you?
moses told of most of these and the Qu'ran is not in agreement with the books of Moses... This book called the Qu'ran is in agreement with Muhammad and no other prophet of God. Well you do have the Qu'ran which is the words of Muahmmad and what he tells youa re thw ords of the others. The Bible has the actual words of the prophets and they are not in agreement with Muhammad, The Qu'ran or Allah whichever you prefer.

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker

My dear ..... There is ONLY ONE GOD. Call Him by any good name you want .... HE IS ONE. Call Him God, Allah, Jehovah, The Power, The Wisdom, The End of Journeys, The Mighty, The High, The Irresistible, The Merciful, The Gracious ....... but KNOW that HE is the "THE" of all good names.

Peace be upon you ....... He is the same God of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Ismail, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Aaron, Zachariah, Mary, John, Jesus and Mohammad .... may peace be on ALL of them.

I love GOD. HE is ONE the rest are NONE

Asker's Rating:

Asker's Comment:

If there is one God who is the same God of Moses and Abraham. Why is this Allah not in agreement with these prophets? Same god different message? unless god serioult has some issues the god of Abraham and Moses and Isiah and Jesus and John the Baptist taught the atonement .. Why did God decide

Answer 2

Some muslims say that our God is not the same as the 'Christian' or 'Jewish' God. 'Allah' is God ... He is the same diety.

We believe in Allah, the Creator of the heavens and the earth, of all the seen and unseen. The same God worshipped by Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus(peace be upon them) AND Muhammad (peace and blessing be upon him). The only difference is how each religion views Him and worships the Almighty.

Answer 3

I won't answer that question until you get theright idea about Islam ..

I disagree that Allah is jesus..I beleive in jesus but I don't beleive he is Allah

Answer 4

The Nature of Allah

Allah Existed before any creature including the human. Allah is the who created all the mankind, the sky, the earth, oceans and seas, the sun, the moon, the stars and every thing you see in this world.

Besides Allah of Noah, Abraham, David, Solomon, Moses, Juses and Mohamed peace be upon them is one and the same. Below verses tel us how Allah has decribed himself. (Qoran, Surah Al-Ikhlaas)

1 Say: He is Allah the One and Only; 6296 6297
2 Allah the Eternal Absolute; 6298
3 He begetteth not nor is He begotten; 6299
4 And there is none like unto Him. 6300

6296 The nature of Allah is here indicated to us in a few words, such as we can understand. The qualities of Allah are described in numerous places elsewhere, e.g., in lix. 22-24, lxii. 1, and ii. 255. Here we are specially taught to avoid the pitfalls into which men and nations have fallen at various times in trying to understand Allah. The first thing we have to note is that His nature is so sublime, so far beyond our limited conceptions, that the best way in which we can realise Him is to feel that He is a Personality, "He", and not a mere abstract conception of philosophy. He is near us; He cares for us; we owe our existence to Him. Secondly, He is the One and Only God, the Only One to Whom worship is due; all other things or beings that we can think of are His creatures and in no way comparable to Him. Thirdly, He is Eternal, without beginning or end, Absolute, not limited by time or place or circumstance, the Reality. Fourthly, we must not think of Him as having a son or a father, for that would be to import animal qualities into our conception of Him. Fifthly, He is not like any other person or thing that we know or can imagine: His qualities and nature are unique. (112.1)

6297 This is to negative the idea of Polytheism, a system in which people believe in gods many and lords many. Such a system is opposed to our truest and profoundest conceptions of life. For Unity in Design, Unity in the fundamental facts of existence, proclaim the Unity of the Maker. (112.1)

6298 Samad is difficult to translate by one word. I have used two, "Eternal" and "Absolute". The latter implies: (1) that absolute existence can only be predicated of Him; all other existence is temporal or conditional; (2) that He is dependent on no person or things, but all persons or things are dependent on Him, thus negativing the idea of gods and goddesses who ate and drank, wrangled and plotted, depended on the gifts of worshippers, etc. (112.2)

6299 This is to negative the Christian idea of the godhead, "the Father", "the only-begotten Son" etc. (112.3)

6300 This sums up the whole argument and warns us specially against Anthropomorphism, the tendency to conceive of Allah after our own pattern, an insidious tendency that creeps in at all times and among all peoples. (112.4)

Source(s):

A. Yusuf Ali Quran Translation Surah Al-Ikhlaas Surah 112Mecca (22) 4 Ayahs

Answer 5

what the hell are you on about?

are you seriously that dumb?

Answer 6

Evidence of God has always been there, as I believe. Yet sometimes people just don't see or ignore it, and that's why God sent us prophets like Muhammad, Jesus, and Moses to remind us of his existence in case we've forgotten.

As to why muslims disagree with Allah as you say, I truly think it's because these people haven't understood Islam the way they should just like some Christians or some jews or hindus... I hope I have answered your question my friend...

LOVE & PEACE

Answer 7

Well unless your a pagan or polytheist your God is not the same. Other then that all Abrahamic religions are based on the same God. Allah(swt) the god of Abraham(pbuh).
Edit: Yes, it is said in the Quran, that Allah is the God of Adam, Adam was the first man.

Answer 8

Christians arabs say Allah 2 its just God in arabic.

Answer 9

Dear, djmantx
I try to answer the question you have asked adamjer. Islam and Mohamed does disagree with what you call trinity. The Almighty God the God of Jesus and Mohamed has clearly refused what christians call trinity and has said in his holy Quran the following
Sura Almaida verse 72, 73, 74, 75, 76
the commentary Follows also refers to some verses of the Bible that disagree with the trinity.
72 They do blaspheme who say: "Allah is Christ the son of Mary." But said Christ: "O children of Israel! worship Allah my Lord and your Lord." Whoever joins other gods with Allah Allah will forbid him the garden and the Fire will be his abode. There will for the wrong-doers be no one to help. 782
73 They do blaspheme who say: Allah is one of three in a Trinity: for there is no god except One Allah. If they desist not from their word (of blasphemy) verily a grievous penalty will befall the blasphemers among them.
74 Why turn they not to Allah and seek His forgiveness? For Allah is Oft-forgiving Most Merciful.
75 Christ the son of Mary was no more than an Apostle; many were the Apostles that passed away before him. His mother was a woman of truth. They had both to eat their (daily) food. See how Allah doth makes His Signs clear to them; yet see in what ways they are deluded away from the truth! 783 784
76 Say: Will ye worship besides Allah something which hath no power either to harm or benefit you? But Allah He it is that heareth and knoweth all things."

Comments and explanations
782 Cf. Matt. iv. 10, where Christ rebukes Satan for desiring the worship of other than Allah: John xx. 17, where Christ says to Mary Magdalene, "Go unto my brethren, and say unto them, I ascend unto my Father and your Father; and to my God and your God." Cf. also Luke xviii. 19, where Christ rebukes a certain ruler for calling him Good Master: "Why callest thou me good? None is good, save One, that is, Allah." In Mark xii. 25 Jesus says: "The first of all the commandments is, Hear O Israel; the Lord our God is One Lord." (5.72)
783 She never claimed that she was a mother of God, or that her son was God. She was a pious virtuous woman. (5.75)
784 Note how logically the argument has led up from Jewish back-slidings and want of faith, to blasphemies associated with the names of Jesus and Mary, and in the following verses to the worship of senseless stocks and stones. Allah is One; His Message is one; yet how people's perversity transforms truth into falsehood, religion into superstition! (5.75)

Answer 10

Almighty GOD is ONE, call HIM by any name. But it should be a Beautiful one WITHOUT any Mental picture.

What we say that there is ONE GOD means HE is the same GOD for Muslims, Christians, Jews, Hindus, Athiests, Buddhists and all mankind.

Because GOD is ONE and for all mankind.

Therefore, if you say ALLAH, ELI, ELIAH, BRAHMA, all refer to GOD. We can best understand this from the Hindu Scripture example.

Hindus say GOD is Brahma. Which if translated into English means 'The Creator' and if translated into Arabic means 'Khaliq'

Therefore if you call Almighty GOD as 'The Creator' OR 'Khaliq' OR 'Brahma' it is ONE and the SAME.

BUT...

The trouble arises when the Hindus ascribe features to GOD that are NOT worthy for GOD. For example, they say Brahma is the GOD who has 10 heads, so and so hands, etc...

And this goes against the fundamentals of Islam, Judaism and Christianity (As per the Gospel of Barnabas) and even True Hinduism itself (Vedas are against this)...

Therefore, All religions speak about Monotheism BUT the True essence of Monotheism has now remained in Islam only as...

1. The Church has fabricated the Trinity and mis-lead the Chirstians from the True message of Jesus Christ (Peace Be Upon Him)

2. The Hindus do NOT read the Vedas and practice Idol worship which is against their own scriptures.

Why does GOD need a Son?? To look after HIM when HE retires???

Why do Christians accept the belief of trinity which was fabricated by the Church. Why dont they apply rational thinking and come to the Truth of the'Original message of Christ (PBUH)'???

Jesus Christ (PBUH) was 100% human. And he had no father. He was born to virgin Mary by the Will of GOD. Infact his birth was a Miracle. He was one of the Mightiest messenger of GOD NOT the Son of GOD.

Is there hierarchy in the Divine kingdom too??? If yes then even Almighty GOD gets into the 'finite' zone.

Therefore to compare the CREATOR with HIS Creation is a big sin. Almighty GOD has NO parallel with respect to HIS creation. HE is beyond imagination, beyond the finite limits of our brains.

Answer 11

Yesterday I referred you quotations from Bible in which Jesus said clearly Father is above all, Father is above me, Even when Jesus on cross He called God by name Eli, Eli, If he is God then To whom He was calling. What logic you have?

God is God, The Almighty God.
God can not be less then God.
God do not need to be less then God.

I invite every one to accept truth. Follow Prophet do not deny and deceive Prophets of God Almighty, as people of ignorant done before.

Jesus (pbuh) cried out Allah Allah when he was put on the cross
It is mentioned in the New Testament in the Gospel of Mathew, chapter 27 verse 46 as well as Gospel of Mark, chapter 15 verse 34 when Jesus (pbuh) was put on the cross.

Jesus cried with a loud voice saying "E’-Li, E’-Li la’-ma sa-bach’-tha-ni?" that is to say, ‘My God, My God why hast Thou Forsaken Me?’ Does this sound like Jehovah! Jehovah! why has thou forsaken me? Does it sound like Abba Abba? The answer is ‘No’. Hebrew and Arabic are sister languages and if you translate "E’-Li, E’-Li la’-ma sa-bach’-tha-ni" into Arabic it is ‘Allah Allah lama tarak tani’ does it sound similar?

This statement of Jesus (pbuh), "E’-Li, E’-Li la’-ma sa-bach’-tha-ni" is preserved in its original Hebrew in each and every of its translation which is available in more than 2000 different languages of the world and in each and every of them, "Allah" is present.

Elohim El, Elah, Alah
In the Bible, God is very often referred to as ‘Elohim’ in the Hebrew language. The ‘im’ in the ending is a plural of honour and God is referred to as ‘El’ or ‘Elah’ in the English Bible with commentary, edited by reverend C. I. Scofield. ‘Elah’ is alternatively spelled as ‘Alah’. The difference in spelling is only of a single ‘L’. Muslims spell Allah as ‘Allah’ while the Reverend has spelled it as Alah and they pronounce it as ‘Elah’. Muslims pronounce it as Allah. Hebrew and Arabic are sister languages therefore we say it should be pronounced as ‘Allah’ and not as ‘Elah’.

When I was in school, I was taught ‘D, O’ is do, ‘T, O’ is to. What is ‘G, O’ It is ‘go’ and not ‘gu’. ‘N, U, T’ is nut, ‘C, U, T’ cut; ‘B, U, T’ is but, what is ‘P, U, T’? Not ‘pat’ but it is ‘put’. If you ask "Why?" The answer is "It is their language". If I have to pass I have to say ‘P, U, T’ is ‘put’ and not ‘pat’. Similarly the right pronunciation for A, L, L, A, H, is Allah.

"Allah" in Hinduism
"Allah" in Rigveda Book 2 Hymn I verse II
Even in the Rigveda which is the most sacred scripture of the Hindus, one of the attributes given to God Almighty in Book no 2 Hymn no I verse II, is ‘Ila’ which if pronounced properly is the same as Allah.

Allo Upanishad:
Amongst the various Upanishads one of the Upanishad is named as ‘Allo’ Upanishad in which God is referred to as "Allah" several times.

http://www.irf.net
http://www.islamreligion.com

Answer 12

No muslim ever disagree regarding God Almighty. He is the One who created this universe, you and me and everythin in. He is One and Only.

He is Allah..

The First: Nothing is before Him.
The Last: Nothing is After Him.
The Most High: Nothing is Above Him.
The Most Near: Nothing is beyond His Reach.
He Begets Not, Nor was He Begotten.
The Creator, Provider, and All-Rich.
The All-Seer, The All-Knower.
He is One and Self-Sufficient.
He is not Nature, or any part of it.
He ascended above His Throne, High above the Seven Skies.
No Vision can encompass Him, but
His Grasp is over all vision..

Such Is Allah
Nothing Is Like Unto Him
The All-Hear, The All-Seer

Answer 13

There is ONE God Allah, He is from ever to ever ...infact time is his creation and even time is huble to him.

Jesus is a Prophet. To him Allah's commandments were revealed! To Moses Allah's Commandments were revealed, and to All other Prophets Allahs Commandments were revealed as Allah willed. Prophet Mohammad is the last Prophet! Allah had already sent more than 100000, Prophets!
All believed there is Only ONE God. How can u say that before Prophet Mohammad (Peace Be Upon Him) No one told about GOD!

All Muslims agree on what I just said...We dont disagree!!
U need to learn more...IMHO.

Answer 14

There is one and only Allah, we don't disagree with the almighty at all

The books reveled to Prophet Moses(PBUH) was onlt to his people of that time. so was the case of Prophet Jesus, as for Prophet Muhammad, he was the last prophet of all, and the book reveled to him was for all humanity, thus giveing the quran impeortance ovet all other books reveled before
Hope the answeres your question

Answer 15

no your miss understood ,what ALLAH wrote in the Quran is meant to be said by another person..that surah Prophet Muhammad s.a.w used during war. my god is your god is a way of saying we may believe in God but we dont have the same religion. this the surah our beloved prophet has said.

"I do not worship what you worship, you are not worshipping what i worship,i will not worship what you have worshipped in the past.nor will you worship what i worship, you have your own religion and i have my religion(islam)." :)