Muslims, was God's word corrupt before the writing of the Qur'an?

Question

If before why does the Qur'an call it holy? If after then why is it the same as copies that predate Muahammed?

Additional Details

Ahmed it wouldn't take very much effort on your part to see the same holy books that predate the Qur'an are still available today.

God'sindigobuttefly Copiest errors??? Saying that Jesus is the only begotten son of God who died to atone for sin is a copiest error or are the Bible and Qu'ran in disagreement and if that be so why would the Qu'ran call it holy?

Stand for truth Why is it not in agreement with God's word? And why does it call the Bible and Torah holy if they were corrupt? If The Bible and all Bibles agree that Christ atoned for sin by being crucified why doesnt the Qu'ran agree?

I could show many contradictions in the Qu'ran and could clear up much of what you consider a contradiction in the Bible the fact that many men wrote the Bible while inspired by God is a testament to the fact that is is from God it is easy for one man to agree with himself. Christ taught that the testimony of one is suspect.

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker

Because before the 11th century the Muslims never accused the Bible of being corrupted until a certain Imam came up with that idea, and then they all started saying it was corrupted.

During the time of Muhammad, even him studied the Torah and the Bible. His first wife's cousin translated them to him. From his very young age he was around people of different faiths. He also said for the people of the book to look into what you have, meaning the Bible, for the truth is within. But the Muslims, like to see what they want to see, and turn a blind eye for what they think it will take something away from them. Think outside of the box, and you will know what I mean.

The problem is that the Muslim refuse to see that the Quran has many contradictions in it, because if it comes directly from Allah it shouldn't have any mistakes in it. But it does, many.
The Christians know that the Bible is inspired by God, but it was written by man.

Muslims you say nothing changed in the Quran! maybe something in it should be corrected, such as what is the center of the universe. The Quran said it is the Earth, and we all know that is false. You might one day try and read your Quran. It is interesting read.

God Bless, and Merry Christmas

Asker's Rating:

Asker's Comment:

May God Bless You and Merry Christmas!!!

Answer 2

The Holy books that came before the Quran sucah as the Bible, Torah and Psalms were actually from God as guidance for the Muslims at that time. However these books were changed.

The Quran is relevent for the whole of mankind for ever, Not a single letter can be changed. For more guidance a Muslim can obtain this from the Hadith.

Source(s):

member of www.yanabi.com

Answer 3

That isn't me, I swear it.

Answer 4

by saying "holy bible" or "holy Torah" we mean the original texts which were revealed on to Prophet Moses & prophet Jesus (peace be upon them) not the ones who who were altered & being called bible & Torah right now

Answer 5

the Quran did not call it holy. but call it with its name. such as Bible called Injiel . and Torah called Al-Towrah.

and God said in the Quran that if he wants he will not let them divide his religion and corrupted. but God does whatever he wants.

[253] ....... If Allâh had willed, succeeding generations would not have fought against each other, after clear Verses of Allâh had come to them, but they differed - some of them believed and others disbelieved. If Allâh had willed, they would not have fought against one another, but Allâh does what He likes.
Quran 2:253

Answer 6

Your question doesn't really make much sense. But, let me add this to clarify a few things. Muslims call three books holy. It's not just the Qu'ran (and that is right...not Qur'an). They also called the Hebrew Scriptures (the Torah) and the Gospels holy. Muhammad was the third prophet in the series of prophets that were sent by God to the world. Allah is God in Arabic. It is not some silly moon god like some people want to believe.

It is the same God of Abraham that Jews and Christians are worshipping. Allah sent Moses as the first prophet, then Christ, and the last installment of the revelation of Allah was Muhammad.

The Qu'ran was written by ONE author unlike the Bible that is written by many and is seriously got some copyist errors in it.

Answer 7

THe Quran states that all relions are under one God.

Answer 8

For ur kind information, when ever God revealed a verse or few it was immediately written down and memorized by many companions. Dring the life of Prophet Muhammed, it was set in order and after his death it was transformed into a book form.
Reasons:
1) Quran is not like Bible, with Contradictions.
2) God said in the Quran tht He is going to save His last message from being Changed.
3) Today u go through out the World and all copies of Quran are same, from the starting letter to the ending letter.
4) Millions and thousands of Muslims have memorised the Quran today.
5) From the life of Propeht Muhammad Quran is being memorised to kids of age 5-10. Or atleast they are being taught how to read it. U can't find any thing similar in any other religion.
6) Mongolians burned the entire Country of Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran and many other parts of Muslim land but still today the Quran is there in more number than Bible.
7) Communist revolution in Russia, all the copies of Quran and all Mosques were burned down or demolished like w/ Bible and Churches. But the Generations of Muslims living during tht Communist revolution, learned the Quran word to word from the other Hufaaz (Learners of Quran) and passed tht on to their kids and even today the Quran in Russia is EXACTLY the same as in any part of the World.


There are all kinds of Different Bibles in the Entire world but only One Quran in the Whole world.
One God
One People
Under the banner of One Religion
With One (Same) Quran

U can't find any thing like tht in any other Religion, Because it is the Last revelation and God Himself has promised to save it from changing.